"If it be now, 'tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now; if it be not now, yet it will come: the readiness is all. Since no man knows aught of what he leaves, what is't to leave betimes? Let be."--Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act IV, Scene II
"He wasn't playing the part, he became it."--Richard Eyre on Ian Charleson
Edinburgh-born actor Ian Charleson hit the cinematic jackpot when Hugh Hudson's Chariots of Fire won the Oscar for Best Picture in 1982. Charleson turned 33 that year, and he had his whole life ahead of him. Though he had a long list of stage credits to his name, Chariots was only his second feature--though producer David Puttnam encouraged him to say it was his first--after boundary-pushing filmmaker Derek Jarman's 1978 Jubilee. He decided to capitalize on the attention to pursue more major studio roles.
Like Charleson, Elsinore director Simon Stone cut his teeth on the stage, first in Melbourne and then in London. Similarly, he didn't trade the stage for the screen when he turned to feature filmmaking, and has maintained a presence in both camps. On paper he seemed like the ideal director to take on the last few months of Charleson's life when he finally lands the biggest role of his career just as a terminal illness has him in its grip. Turns out: Stone was the ideal director, especially in terms of his feel for the material.
It would have been for nought, though, if he hadn't found the ideal actor. No matter that brown-eyed Andrew Scott was born and bred in Dublin, or that he's a decade older than Charleson was in 1989. He looks young enough, has been out since 2013 (Scott rejects the term "openly gay"), nails Charleson's Scottish-inflected London accent, and, well, he's been fitted with blue contact lenses that are more intense than Charleson's light, greenish-blue eyes, but it's the performance that counts, and the Irishman gives it everything he's got, bolstered by a reported 150 of his own appearances as Hamlet.
The film opens on an actor who hits the highest of highs, only to find the anticipated movie career more elusive than he expected. Not that he ever stopped working, but the prestigious roles stop coming, even though he appeared in another Best Picture winner, Gandhi, the following year.
I get why Stephen Beresford, writer of 2014's Thatcher-era docudrama Pride, leaves that out of his otherwise persuasive screenplay--unless I missed it--but starring in two back-to-back Oscar winners is no small feat.
It's to Scott's credit that Charleson never comes across as a gloomy character, and the film doesn't lack for some well-placed humor, even as his circumstances grow increasingly dire. (Like Ian McKellen, who ran in the same circles, he calls everyone "darling.") His feelings of disappointment come through loud and clear, but it's never a drag to spend time with him, even as he has every reason to sink into despair. Just three years before, he had been diagnosed with HIV: a death sentence. That hadn't changed in 1989, and he knows what's coming; he just doesn't know when it will come.
So, it adds to the sense of urgency. Not only is Charleson finding fewer leading movie roles as he enters middle age, i.e. none, but he knows he won't make it to 50; if anything, he'll be lucky to make it to 41. Time is running out, and he longs to make the most of it.It helps that he isn't alone. He has several friends cheering him on, and Stone focuses primarily on steadfast director Sean Mathias (The Testament of Ann Lee's Matthew Beard), effusive casting director Patsy Pollock (an unrecognizably brunette Billie Piper) and Patsy's adoring teenage daughter, Alice (Saltburn's Sadie Soverall). It isn't mentioned in the film, but in 1989, Charleson appeared in a one-night performance of Mathias's play Bent to benefit LGBTQ charity Stonewall. If he wasn't out publicly, he didn't completely avoid gay actors, writers, directors, or even material, though he didn't embrace it either, a point of contention between him and Jarman.
Bent might have represented Charleson's last stage role, but for a twist of fate. The hot ticket at the time was Richard Eyre's Hamlet at the National Theater with Daniel Day-Lewis, who had recently made his mark on the silver screen in My Beautiful Laundrette and Room with a View.
Left: Daniel Day-Lewis in the 1989 HamletNow semi-retired, Day-Lewis has since won two Oscars, but I can't imagine he's thrilled by Elsinor's existence, since it revives a time in his life when the role, and possibly the circumstances, overwhelmed him. He broke down, dropped out mid-performance, and left the theater for good. To his credit, Stone doesn't linger on the episode, though there's no mention of the fact that understudy Jeremy Northam took over the role for Day-Lewis's remaining seven contractual performances.
London's theatrical community, including Charleson, is all abuzz with the news of Day-Lewis's sudden departure, but life goes on. He visits a doctor regularly and stands in front of a mirror daily to check his body for Kaposi sarcoma, a sign that he would have full-blown AIDs. He also, wisely, rejects an offer to try Azidothymidine, aka AZT, knowing that it will only do more harm than good, but less invasive antiviral treatments are still years away.
Then Eyre (Johnny Flynn, who played off Scott so wonderfully in Ripley) calls him about the play, just as the first KP lesion appears on Charleson's face. He agrees to meet with the director, knowing that he probably won't get the part if he reveals his status, though it would be dishonest not to disclose. It's a risk either way, but he does the honorable thing, and Eyre doesn't flinch. He has his concerns, of course, but agrees to keep it a secret.
Everyone is thrilled, but you can't fool theater people. Charleson invents a story about the lesion, and his new colleagues appear to believe it, until costume designer Ralph (Paul Chahidi), takes him aside, and recommends he pay a visit to Dr. Margaret Johnson (fellow Fleabag player Olivia Colman in an effectively tamped-down turn), an innovator in the treatment of HIV and AIDS. Their meetings continue throughout the film as Dr. Johnson does all she can to prolong his life while he takes on one of theater's most challenging roles--I mean, it broke Daniel Day-Lewis, of all people! (At the time, he claimed he saw the ghost of his late father, Cecil Day-Lewis, on stage, but later explained that he didn't mean it literally.)There's a predictability to this development as Dr. Johnson eventually comes around, stops disparaging a role that means the world to her patient--even as it's taking a physical toll--and even attends one of his performances, but it's also the crux of the film. Without Hamlet, Charleson might live a little longer, but it's his dream, and it's within his grasp. How can he refuse?
By this point, he's all-in on theater anyway, and hasn't had any feature work since Dario Argento's 1987 Opera. Horror isn't the actor's usual purview, but it's among the Italian maestro's best loved films, even if Elsinore gives it short shrift. I watched it in light of the new film and was surprised to find that it's a better fit for Charleson's sensibilities than I expected.
Left: Ian Charleson with Cristina Marsillach and Daria Nicolodi in OperaThe actor plays Marco, director of a production of Giuseppe Verdi's 1847 opera of Macbeth, and the guy certainly knows his way around Shakespeare. At one point, Marco even quotes, to the film's Lady Macbeth, from Hamlet (Act III, Scene I): "To sleep: perchance to dream: ay, there's the rub; for in that sleep of death what dreams may come." I would be surprised if that wasn't an improv on Charleson's part.
With the actor, who had worked with Eyre on Guys and Dolls, now firmly attached to Hamlet, Stone goes through all the phases of the production, from rehearsals to his first triumphant performance. Sylvia Syms (Juliet Stevenson, who appeared with Scott in Robert Ickes' 2018 Hamlet), the play's Gertrude, often looks at him curiously, and it isn't clear at first if she suspects he has AIDS and disapproves of his involvement, or if she suspects he has AIDS and worries for his welfare–both can be true. It helps to have an actress of Stevenson's caliber in such a small, but crucial role, because she conveys all of this curiosity and concern without saying a word.
As Charleson's health declines, he struggles to keep up with the death-haunted play, but a harrowing downturn forces him to take time off to recover, in hopes that he can return. Around this time, he reaches out to his parents, Jack (Peter Mullan) and Jean (Call the Midwife's Georgie Glen).
Near as I can tell, he had drifted away from his parents, who probably didn't know he was gay, let alone that he had AIDS, but they rise to the occasion, and when the gravity of the situation hits Jack full force, his cry of anguish is shattering. In that moment, I was reminded of Mullan's brilliant turns in Ken Loach's My Name Is Joe and Paddy Considine's Tyrannosaur with Colman; any actor can depict pain, but only a rare few can make you feel it, too. He's truly one of the best there is. (They don't appear in the film, but Charleson had siblings, too.)
It's now impossible for the actor to hide his condition from Hamlet's cast and crew. Upon his return, he reveals the truth, and each of them embraces him in turn (those who were there at the time have confirmed that this really happened). I found it terribly moving, since the idea that you couldn't even touch a person with HIV or AIDS was still pervasive in some quarters.
Fortunately, these quarters are different, and Stone pays tribute to the theater, particularly the London theater, as much as to Charleson and other talents cut short by AIDS. It's little surprise, really, that his colleagues wouldn't reject him because of his illness, though the similarly-afflicted Derek Jarman (David Dawson) criticizes him for keeping his status private, except Charleson has a plan, and he'll see it through. He plays Hamlet for 24 performances, after which he has nothing left to give and dies eight weeks later, but he had arranged to have the cause of his death made public.
Jarman outlived Charleson by four years, and though the film suggests the two made their peace toward the end of the actor's life, Jarman's diaries tell a different story. Including his myth-puncturing perspective in the film adds value, but Beresford could have stuck closer to the facts with no loss of impact.
Even so, I wouldn't want the too-blue contact lenses or softening of certain developments to obscure Charleson's near-miraculous achievement or Andrew Scott's absolute triumph in bringing it to vibrant life.
We have to take it on faith that Charleson gave one of the greatest performances as Hamlet, because there's no recorded evidence and that's what London theater critics of the time proclaimed, but Scott has a double role as both doomed British actor and doomed Danish prince, and he excels at both. He's so good as Charleson, in fact, that it feels as if the role were written specifically to his talents, except this wasn't a fictional character, but a real person, one of "all too solid flesh," as Hamlet describes himself.
I thought Scott hit a peak with Andrew Haigh's 2023 metaphysical romance All of Us Strangers as a lonely gay screenwriter alternately reliving the life he had and the one he desires, but he surpasses his own high standards here as an actor who fought against every obstacle to give the performance of a lifetime, and that's exactly how Scott plays him: as if he were in Charleson's shoes, staring down oblivion with all the passion, conviction, and unbridled love of the craft any one man could muster.
Elsinore opens in limited release Nov 20 and in Seattle at SIFF Cinema Downtown Nov 25. Images from Empire (Andrew Scott), Alamy / BBC (Ian Charleson), the IMDb (Scott with Matthew Beard, Charleson in Opera, and Charleson portrait), and Tristram Kenton / The Guardian (Daniel Day-Lewis).







No comments:
Post a Comment