Friday, June 26, 2026
A Restless Spirit on an Endless Flight: Canadian Filmmaker Avalon Fast’s Enchanting CAMP
Wednesday, June 17, 2026
Silas Howard and Harry Dodge Put a Queer Spin on the Buddy Comedy in Charming San Francisco Picaresque By Hook or by Crook
BY HOOK OR BY CROOK
(Silas Howard and Harry Dodge, 2001, USA, 100 minutes)
"I'm a special; a two for one."
--Valentine (Harry Dodge)
Co-directors Silas Howard and Harry Dodge's By Hook or by Crook opens with home-movie footage of a father playing with a boyish tyke in a Superman cape. In voice-over, Shy (Silas Howard, who also co-produced) explains that he was that kid, and that he just wanted to jump, to fly.
In the present, things haven't quite worked out that way. His loving father recently passed away--he never really knew his mother--and he has just received notice that their Hoxie, Kansas home is being repossessed. Shy, a loner who likes to smoke, lift weights in a "Simply the Best" muscle tee, and "jam out to Sabbath," as he puts it, has 48 hours to find new digs.
Though Shy's neighborhood seems more downmarket than not, Go Fish cinematographer Ann T. Rossetti, shooting in MiniDV, shows it to its best advantage. It isn't so much about glamorizing an un-pretty place, but finding the beauty in the quotidian, like a freight train glowing in the sun.
Left: Guinevere Turner and V.S. Brodie in Go FishSilas earns his keep by washing dishes, and he's barely scraping by. While watching a news report one night about a heist involving an attractive, dark-haired thief (Joan Jett!), he comes up with a solution. Soon, he puts on a suit, packs a bag, and hitchhikes to San Francisco, where he aims to put his plan into action. I'm not sure where the suit, which he pairs with a glittery shirt, comes in, but it's a good look.
Shy meets Valentine (Dodge, an author and visual artist who uses he/him pronouns in real life), a butch dyke with an odd little beard, when he steps in to stop a bully from beating her up. Val, who has been on her own since she was 13, starts following Shy around, talking a mile a minute, fueled by a combination of gratitude and the recognition that he's also a gender outlaw, to borrow a term from trans elder Kate Bornstein. When a little girl asks Shy, "Are you a boy or a girl?," he smiles and says, "Both," without hesitation.
If the actor/directors have an instant rapport, it could be down to acting, but they had also been friends for 15 years by the time they made their feature, even running a tiny Bay Area café and performance space called Red Dora's The Bearded Lady where cabaret duo Kiki and Herb frequently performed.
Right: Harry Dodge and Silas Howard at the Bearded LadyShy and Val proceed to spend a night on the town, eating crullers and visiting lesbian bar The Lexington, also long gone, filled with every kind of person.
There's a neat montage in which customer after customer poses for the characters or for Rossetti's camcorder--both, really--and it's clear that the new friends fit right in.
Shy, however, still has money--or the lack thereof--on his mind, and ghosts Val while she's dancing up a storm, making sure to pick a customer's pocket on the way out, but he reconnects with Val and his girlfriend, Billie (Stanya Kahn, Dodge's longtime artistic collaborator), the next day. The first thing they do is to run a scam on a clerk at a hardware store after which they enjoy a rather unusual homemade dinner.
While planning and plotting other ways to make money, they get to know each other better. Though Val's motormouth, physically-expressive affect is amusing, and somewhat reminiscent of Dustin Hoffman's Ratso Rizzo in Midnight Cowboy--also made by a queer filmmaker--she isn't simply cute and quirky, but mentally imbalanced, and admits she's spent time in a mental institute. Val appears to be schizophrenic; I wasn’t sure, but she can be sad and weird in ways that don't/aren't meant to make complete sense.
When Shy finds out that Val is committed to finding her birth mother, he decides to help, which proves personally advantageous. If Val starts out as the one with a lady love, Shy hits it off with a no-bullshit Vital Records staffer (Carina Gia). While mainstream 1990s films with queer characters tended to be rather skittish about sex, Howard and Dodge give the people what they want, which is satisfying sexual experiences for their characters.
Billie also joins in on some of their schemes, but it's Shy and Val who attract the wrong kind of attention, leading them to put the planning and plotting on hold as the narrative briefly enters One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest territory before ending on a considerably more positive note.
If anything, the ending is especially touching for keeping things understated after a few sequences that felt overstated.
Beyond the chemistry between the leads and the sensitive cinematography from Rosetti, the film has an absolutely kick-ass soundtrack, filled by music from composer Carla Bozulich of the Geraldine Fibbers featuring the ace guitar-playing of Nels Cline, who would join Wilco just three years later.
Bozulich also served as music supervisor, and she did an incredible job. I swear I'm not biased, though I've met a few of these musicians, since she includes Pacific Northwest acts Jessamine and the Mono Men, in addition to Tom Robinson, the Make Up, Low, Blonde Redhead, and of course, Tribe 8, the Geraldine Fibbers, and Joan Jett--you can guess what song she covers.
By letting Shy and Val be who they are, rather than trying to define them, By Hook or by Crook feels not necessarily timeless, but less frozen-in-amber than I would have expected. Even the terms I've mentioned, like queer, trans, and bull dyke, don't appear in the film (unless I missed them).
Nonetheless, Dave Kehr, in his New York Times review, wrote, "It is, indeed, hard to keep track of the fluid genders in this independent feature shot on digital video, which proclaims itself ''a movie about butches by butches'."
For my money, there's nothing confusing about that fluidity. It helps that the film hews to a certain 1970s aesthetic, though I couldn't say whether that was intentional or not, but I was reminded of Jerry Schatzberg's Scarecrow, in addition to Barbara Loden's Wanda and John Huston's latter-period literary adaptations, like Fat City and Wise Blood, more in terms of the working-class milieu than the hetero characters or downbeat narratives.
Right: Al Pacino and Gene Hackman in Scarecrow also smoking up a storm
Other latter-period films that came to mind include Allan Moyle's Times Square--which also boasts a kick-ass soundtrack--and Annette Haywood-Carter's Joyce Carol Oates adaptation Foxfire.
Significantly though, both films had to tone down the queer content due to studio pressure. Berkeley filmmaker Jenni Olson, who served as a consulting producer on By Hook or by Crook, has done some of the best writing on Times Square as a queer text, so I was happy to see that she lent her expertise to a film, made outside of the studio system and largely funded by friends, that doesn't play things quite so safe.
Until this year, I hadn't heard of the film, though I'm familiar with some of the projects on which the principals have worked, like Transparent and Pose for which Howard served as a director, so I kept my expectations in check, though I took the number of prestigious entities behind the 4K restoration, especially the UCLA Film & Television Archive, as a promising sign.
By Hook or by Crook also won the Audience Award for Best Narrative Feature at 2002's Sundance Film Festival--and has received praise from discerning critics, like Willow Maclay, coauthor of Corpses, Fools and Monsters--so I'm even more surprised that I hadn't heard of it, but Altered Innocence, which specializes in LGBTQ films both new and old, has been getting the word out in a big way, and the filmmakers have been doing all they can to support the re-release. Mostly though, it’s just really good.
Though the filmmakers would part ways geographically when Silas Howard moved to New York and Harry Dodge moved to Los Angeles, they remain connected--Howard is godfather to Dodge and Maggie Nelson's son Iggy.
Unstreamable presents By Hook or by Crook at Northwest Film Forum from June 17 through June 21. A DVD, Blu-ray, and digital release will follow later this summer. Images from Altered Innocence, The Guardian (Go Fish), Lost Womyn's Space (Bearded Lady friends), and the IMDb (Scarecrow).
Friday, June 12, 2026
I'm Tense and Nervous, and I Can't Relax: On Cindy Sherman's Underappreciated Office Killer
Sunday, June 7, 2026
Lost and Found Film Reviews: Gus Van Sant's Milk and Malcolm Ingram's Small Town Gay Bar
Tuesday, May 26, 2026
Bob Fosse, Lenny Bruce, Honey and Kitty Bruce, and Fosse’s Bleak as Hell Biopic Lenny
Saturday, May 23, 2026
Lost and Found Family-Oriented Film Reviews: Graduation and Rachel Getting Married
Monday, May 18, 2026
SIFF Dispatch #7: Music, Movement, and Community in Sky Hopinka's Powwow People
POWWOW PEOPLE
(Sky Hopinka, USA, 2025,
88 minutes)
It takes a village to make a feature, and Sky Hopinka (Ho-Chunk, Pechanga) assembled the equivalent to make Powwow People; one in front of the camera and the other behind the scenes.
Adam Piron (Kiowa, Mohawk), Sterlin Harjo (Seminole, Muscogee)--the creator of Reservation Dogs and The Lowdown–and other prominent Native American figures helped to produce the documentary, Hopinka's second full-length after 2020's maɬni – towards the ocean, towards the shore.
Danny Glover's Louverture Films, known for backing projects of cultural importance, also loaned their support. Julian Brave NoiseCat (Secwepemc), the co-director of 2024's Sugarcane, even shows up as a dancer in the film.
Since 2014, Ferndale-born Hopinka has worked primarily on short films, seven of which Seattle Film Critics Society presented on May 15 at Northwest Film Forum (below right). Eric Zhu, who put together the program, also presented Hopinka with SFCS's John Hartl Pacific Northwest Spotlight Award on May 17 after a SIFF screening of Powwow People.
Hopinka built his second feature, which premiered at last year's Cannes Film Festival, around an opportunity he created in 2023 for Indigenous singers, dancers, and drummers to come together to celebrate their culture, knowing that he would be documenting the whole thing for posterity.
Though the film plays as one day, the event took place from August 22-24 at Daybreak Star Indian Cultural Center in Seattle. Throughout, Hopinka shows the hard work and camaraderie that goes into putting together a powwow, an event with which another recent Pacific Northwest feature culminates: Fancy Dance from Erica Tremblay (Seneca–Cayuga Nation) with Lily Gladstone (Piegan Blackfeet, Nez Perce), first recipient of the John Hartl Award.
As a structuring and thematic device, Hopinka follows four individuals: the down-to-Earth Gina Bluebird-Stacona (Oglala Lakota), who works on setup, the avuncular Ruben Little Head (Northern Cheyenne), the master of ceremonies, the soft-spoken Jamie John (Anishinaabe), a jingle dress dancer, and Cozad (Kiowa), a family drum group named after the gracious Freddie Cozad, a veteran drummer who had hoped to attend. He passed away that November, but Hopinka interviewed him earlier in the spring about powwowing, and his words form part of the communal voice-over.
It says something about the Pacific Northwest that there's so much tribal diversity, though some participants came from as far away as Alberta.
In his opening remarks, Little Head makes it clear that trans and nonbinary members are welcome--Jamie John describes themselves as gender non-conforming--which recalls Hopinka's Standing Rock short "Dislocation Blues," in which speaker Shaawan Francis Keahna (White Earth Band of Minnesota Ojibwe and Meskwaki) identifies as nonbinary.Bearings established, the bulk of the film plays as a riot of color, movement, and sound. Beyond the singers, dancers, and drummers, vendors sell food ("Navajo Fry Bread & Tacos" reads one sign), jewelry, and other handmade items, from t-shirts and hoodies to salmon for two dollars an ounce.
I particularly enjoyed the free-spirited dancing of the Tiny Tots; most in Native regalia, but a few in conventional summer clothes. Some dance in a traditional manner, others just bop about to "Old McDonald Had a Farm" performed on tribal drums--and all receive "day money" for their efforts.
I'm sure most of these dancers would perform for cultural and social reasons without the lure of awards, but dancers in every category qualify for prizes including retro jackets and cash--adults can win as much as $4,000. The film ends with an unbroken 30-minute take centered on an elimination round, adding a little tension to Hopinka's pure cinema approach.
New Mexico filmmaker Shaandiin Tome (Diné) served as cinematographer, while Hopinka provided additional camera work. The results prove less experimental than I expected based on his short films, but there's always something engaging happening on screen. In his work as a whole, he sometimes blurs images while transitioning from one sequence to another.
In the case of Powwow People, he mostly applies the blurring to the bright, beaded, shimmering, and feathered costumes. It's a lovely effect.
Other than the voices in the film and a few on-screen inter-titles, Hopinka doesn't spell anything out explicitly, so Powwow People works more as an experiential documentary than an educational one by allowing viewers to see and hear what it might be like to attend or participate in a powwow.
I wouldn’t have minded subtitles for song lyrics, but I suspect he left them off intentionally, since there's more focus on sounds than words. Beyond the drumming and chanting, others include the ringing metal of the jingle dancers' outfits.
Of Hopinka's short films, Powwow People most closely resembles 2017's Dislocation Blues and 2021's Kicking the Clouds, particularly when speakers share memories of their ancestors. The film, as a whole, serves as a form of collective memory by capturing ancestral traditions on film while simultaneously creating new ancestral memories for future generations.
Click here for more SIFF 2026 coverage, starting with Mārama.
There are no more Seattle-area screenings scheduled for Powwow People, but I'll update this post when that changes, streaming opportunities included. Images from Museum of Modern Art, Me (Sky Hopinka), Seattle Met (Ruben Little Head), Michael Sicinski (Tiny Tot), and In Review Online.
.jpg)


%20and%20Silas%20Howard%20Courtesy%20of%20Altered%20Innocence.jpg)


%20and%20Harry%20Dodge%20Courtesy%20of%20Altered%20Innocence.jpg)









